Entries by category: Migration


Asylum seekers arriving by boat

Asylum seekers who arrive in Australia by boat and their treatment by the federal government has attracted much attention recently.  The United Nations Refugee Agency (UNHCR) is seeking details from the Australian authorities about recent media reports of the Australian Navy forcing boats, presumed to be carrying asylum-seekers on their way to Australia, back into Indonesian territorial waters, as well as reports of plans to buy and provide vessels for future push-backs.

'UNHCR would be concerned by any policy or practice that involved pushing asylum-seeker boats back at sea without a proper consideration of individual needs for protection. Any such approach would raise significant issues and potentially place Australia in breach of its obligations under the Refugee Convention and other international law obligations.

As past experience has shown, such practices are also operationally difficult and potentially dangerous for all concerned.'

Source: 'UNHCR seeking details on reports of boats forced back from Australia', Briefing Notes, 10 January 2014.  For more details, see 'Towbacks may breach international law, UN refugee agency cautions Abbott', The Guardian Australia, 11 January 2014.

The UNHCR has produced a factsheet about refugees and asylum seekers in Australia, September 2013.

Three refugees who arrived by boat and have been refused permanent visas have had appeals lodged in the High Court.  If successful, this could have implications for other asylum seekers already in Australia wanting to make a claim for a permanent protection visa.  For more details, see 'High Court challenge could enable asylum seekers to stay in Australia' by Lenore Taylor, The Guardian Australia, 14 January 2014.

Our Research Guide Human Rights: HSC Legal Studies – asylum seekers and refugees has been updated to include recent developments.  This would be an interesting topic to follow while studying human rights issues in Australia.  


Boat arrivals and people smugglers to be stopped

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd has announced the Labor party's tough new stance against asylum seekers arriving in Australia by boat, as well as indicating a crackdown against people smugglers - those responsible for boat arrivals in Australia.  In 2012, the total number of people who arrived in Australia by boat was 17,202.  This year, the number of boats has not abated and in recent weeks, a number of people who boarded boats to come to Australia have died before arriving.  This is a highly-emotive and politically-charged issue and the population of Australia is sharply divided on the subject of asylum seekers arriving by boat.

The announcement concerning asylum seekers, made on 19 July, is called the Australia and Papua New Guinea Regional Settlement Arrangement.  Prime Minister Rudd announced:

'As of today asylum seekers who come here by boat without a visa will never be settled in Australia.  Under the new arrangement signed with Papua New Guinea today – the Regional Settlement Arrangement - unauthorised arrivals will be sent to Papua New Guinea for assessment and if found to be a refugee will be settled there.  Arriving in Australia by boat will no longer mean settlement in Australia.  Australians have had enough of seeing people drowning in the waters to our north.  Our country has had enough of people smugglers exploiting asylum seekers and seeing them drown on the high seas.'  See media release.

Transcript of the joint press conference on 19 July 2013 – Prime Minister of Australia, Prime Minister of Papua New Guinea, Minister for Immigration, Attorney-General will give you more detailed information about this new arrangement and Prime Minister Rudd's intention to review the United Nations Convention on Refugees.

Response of the media:

Statistics on boat arrivals

Targeting people smugglers

The Minister for Home Affairs and Justice, Jason Clare, announced that the Australian Federal Police will pay rewards of up to $200,000 for information leading to the arrest and conviction of people organising people smuggling ventures to Australia. 

'There are criminals in Australia that are part of international people smuggling syndicates. These syndicates stretch from Australia to Indonesia and to places like Malaysia, Pakistan, Iran and Iraq.  Australian based people smugglers help to organise passengers, collect payments and transfer money overseas.  These people are peddling in misery and death. We need to shut this market down. That’s why we are putting a bounty on their heads.'  See media release.

For more information about asylum seekers and refugees and Australia’s response to their plight, see our Research Guide HSC Legal Studies: Human Rights – Asylum seekers and refugees.  You will find helpful information under the tab 'Human Rights in Australia'.  Note that you can use the tabs along the top of the guide to find information on a range of human rights topics and issues.


High Court decision - ASIO and refugee protection visa

The High Court, in a majority decision on 5 October 2012, ruled invalid a regulation that prevented the issue of a protection visa to a refugee with an adverse security finding made against them by ASIO. This meant that the refusal of the visa based on that regulation was a decision ‘not made according to law’.

The plaintiff, identified as ‘M47’, is a Sri Lankan national who arrived in Australia in December 2009, and has been held in detention since that time. He was granted refugee status on the basis of a ‘well-founded fear of persecution’ on the basis of his race or political opinion. He was however refused a protection visa because ASIO had assessed him as a risk to national security. A clause within the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) has a criterion for providing a visa (called ‘public interest criterion 4002’), which requires that the applicant has not had an assessment made that they are a risk to security under the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation Act 1979 (Cth).

Here are some newspaper articles which discuss the case, before and after the decision:

Freedom or a life without liberty?’ by Michael Gordon, SMH, 5 /10/2012

High Court rules ASIO powers on refugee decisions are invalid’ by Michael Gordon, SMH, 5/10/2012 

A media release by the Australian Human Rights Commission has welcomed the decision and called for an immediate reconsideration of more than 50 other refugees in the same situation.

The High Court has provided a summary of the case and the full decision is also available on AustLII.

Listen to the ABC Law Report on the High Court decision, or read the transcript of the program, broadcast on Tuesday 9 October, 2012.


Report on asylum seekers

The Report of the Expert Panel on Asylum Seekers was released on 13 August 2012. The panel was given the task of reporting on the best way to prevent asylum seekers risking their lives trying to reach Australia by sea.

Members of the panel were

  • Air Chief Marshal Angus Houston (retired), former chief of Australia's defence force
  • Mr Paris Aristotle, Director of the Victorian Foundation for Survivors of Torture Inc
  • Professor Michael L'Estrange, Director of the National Security College, Australian National University.

The report's 22 recommendations include offshore processing of asylum seekers on Manus Island and Nauru. The recommendations have been accepted by the government and opposition and parliament has since passed legislation. See the full report or read sections of it.

The article 'Gillard backs experts' asylum seeker report' by Philiip Coorey, SMH, 13 August 2012 includes commentary on the report and a video of the panel members answering questions from the press.

The Parliament of Australia has passed a bill, Migration Legislation Amendment (Regional Processing and Other Measures) Bill 2012 that, once given Royal Assent, will become law.

'Senate passes offshore processing bill', ABC website, 17 August 2012.



Refugees and people seeking humanitarian protection

The 2012-13 Federal Budget was brought down on 8th May 2012. The Refugee Council of Australia have analysed the budget and what it means for Australia's Refugee and Humanitarian Program.

There will be no new places in the next year with the Program remaining static at 13,750 places – 6000 Refugee Program places, and 7750 places for the Special Humanitarian Program and onshore protection visa allocations combined. Funding of $20.2 million over two years will go towards support of unaccompanied humanitarian minors.

Read the budget report by the Refugee Council of Australia.

The NSW Auditor-General has also released a report called 'Settling Humanitarian Entrants in New South Wales' which looked at the support services provided.

The report found that unlike most of the other states NSW does not have a single point of contact for people entering via the humanitarian program. Consequently entrants are doing less well than in other states on health, housing and employment.

Read the media release and full report published by the Auditor-General.



[ Newer entries | Home | Older entries ]


Interested in finding out what's been in the news about the law?

Are you studying HSC Legal Studies and need help identifying recent legal issues?

More about this blog ›

About the team ›

Follow us on social media:

Recent Entries

No recent entries.

Blog Archive

8 9 10 11 12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22 23 24 25 26 27 28
29 30      
to top of page
To top